Reflections on faith, leadership, and the ministry of accompaniment in a Catholic Jesuit school community
There are moments in leadership for which no preparation is sufficient. For me, one of them came on a Saturday afternoon: a telephone call that would profoundly shift the priorities of our entire school community.
I will not try to describe the grief of the families who were directly impacted. That sorrow belongs to them, and it deserves our silence as much as our words. I write only about what I experienced and learned in the days that followed, and I offer it with humility.
The days that followed brought difficult conversations, sleepless nights, and the responsibility of gathering accurate information so that we could communicate thoughtfully and compassionately with those affected. My thoughts moved between the families, the students who would return carrying grief, and the faculty and staff who would care for them while grieving themselves. We had a crisis plan, but I quickly recognized that even the most thoughtful plan must be adapted to meet the human needs of the moment. We needed clear communication, structure, and a way forward. I also knew that no plan could take away anyone’s pain. Everything I had studied about leadership felt like it was bending under the weight.
On Monday morning, I walked into our building and felt the quiet. The hallways were familiar, but the air was not. Students and adults were arriving with emotions they had not yet found words to express. Before our morning assembly, I kept asking what our students needed to hear and how I could offer reassurance when I was uncertain myself.
Then, in the middle of those questions, I felt a peace. Nothing had changed. No question had been answered, and the grief had not lessened. It was the peace I have come to recognize when I quiet my thoughts, release my expectations, and allow God’s grace to move. It was not an escape from my responsibility. It was a reminder that I did not have to carry it alone.
That is the insight I want to share. Surrender is not the absence of leadership. Sometimes it is leadership’s most necessary expression. I did not surrender my responsibility as President. I surrendered the assumption that my knowledge, experience, and preparation would be enough.
Once I let go of that assumption, I began to see what was already happening around me. After a weekend of deliberation, coordination, and collaboration, our Principal gave the day its structure. Our Campus Minister led us through the Ignatian Examen. The Jesuit Superior presided over a special Mass. Students formed prayer circles, sat quietly beside friends, and prayed for and with one another across different religious traditions. My task was to trust those gifts, not to replace them.
What I witnessed that morning did not begin with the tragedy. It reflected a community formed over time to recognize the dignity of every person, care for one another, and seek God’s presence even in moments of uncertainty. Our Catholic Jesuit identity did not give us all the answers. It gave us a way to respond and a way to proceed. The strength of a school’s mission is revealed not simply in how well it is articulated, but in how deeply it has formed a community to care for one another.
I also came to understand the Ignatian tradition of accompaniment more deeply. Accompaniment is not about finding the right words or attempting to resolve another person’s grief. It is about being present, listening, and recognizing that sometimes our most meaningful response is simply to remain beside one another. I watched our students, faculty, and staff demonstrate this through quiet acts of compassion, often without realizing the significance of what they were offering.
The Examen deserves a closer word because it taught me something. This Ignatian practice invites us to pause, reflect upon our experiences, acknowledge our emotions, recognize God’s presence, and consider how we are being called to respond. In a week when I felt pressure to act quickly, it reminded me that noticing is itself a form of leadership. Some decisions required immediate action. Others required patience, listening, and trust. Learning to tell the difference was part of the discipline of those days.
I should also be honest about my own position. I am not Catholic, yet I serve as President and Director of the Work of a Jesuit apostolate. Watching our community that week, I was reminded that the invitation of Catholic Jesuit education extends beyond those who share the Catholic faith. Our students did not need identical beliefs to recognize the dignity of a classmate’s life or to understand the importance of praying for one another. Our Catholic identity does not require us to diminish our religious differences. Rather, it calls us to recognize the dignity of every person and provides a shared foundation for compassion, service, and care.
We did not have all the answers. We could not remove the grief or change what had happened. But we could choose to be present, to pray, and to accompany one another.
I continue to hold the families in prayer. Their grief does not end with the days we gathered, and our care for them must not end either.
As I continue to reflect on this experience, I invite you to consider two questions: Where am I trying to carry something that was never meant to be carried alone? And who around me is already offering a gift I have not yet allowed myself to receive?
May our answers lead us to become more attentive to the people entrusted to our care, more willing to accompany those who suffer, and more open to the grace that moves through our communities.
Peace and blessings,
Walt D. Reap Sr., President
Cristo Rey Jesuit High School -Baltimore
